clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Travis McKie vs. Harrison Barnes for ACC FOY

By Riley Johnston

 

Photos-wake-forest-vs-unc-greensboro-12-15-10_medium

VS.

Harrison-barnes_display_image_original_original_original_crop_340x234_medium

This post is sponsored by Bud Light

As we begin to wind this season up (especially for Wake Forest), really the only questions that are left to be answered are: Will Wake Forest win another game, or set an ACC record for losses in a season (24), as well as losses in the ACC in one season (15), and if Travis McKie can win ACC Freshman of the Year.

Kyrie Irving probably would have taken the honors if he had no gone down with his toe injury so early in the year. Harrison Barnes had extremely lofty expectations set for him before the season began, and just in the past month has started to live up to them. Travis McKie has gone mostly under the radar, as he came in with four other freshman, and Wake Forest has been historically bad.

Click through to check out stats for McKie and Barnes, and which player should win FOY in the ACC.

 

 Player Team MIN PTS REB AST TO A/T STL BLK PF FG% FT% 3P% PPS

 

 Overall

 

 

 Travis McKie WFU 30.9 12.6 7.5 1 2.1 0.46 0.9 1 2.3 0.48 0.75 0.292 1.35

 

 

 Harrison Barnes UNC 27.6 13.4 5.6 1.4 1.9 0.74 0.6 0.5 1.8 0.403 0.716 0.319 1.13

 

 

 Conference Only MIN FG FGA FTM FTA 3PM 3PA PTS OFF DEF TOT AST TO STL BLK PF

 

 

 Travis McKie WFU 32 4.4 9.8 1.9 2.7 0.6 1.8 11.3 2.5 4.6 7.1 0.7 2 1 1.2 2

 

 

 Harrison Barnes UNC 27.8 5.6 12.8 2.5 3.5 1.5 4.7 15.2 1.8 3.8 5.5 1 2 0.4 0.6 1.5

 

 

 Tempo Free Stats Team %Min ORtg %Poss %Shots eFG% TS% OR% DR% ARate TORate Blk% Stl% FC/40 FD/40 FTRate

 

 

 Travis McKie WFU 77.3 103.6 21.5 22.4 50.8 55.7 9.1 17.7 7.3 17.4 3 1.7 2.9 4.4 44.4

 

 National Rank 384 478 433 369 404 410

 

 

 Harrison Barnes UNC 69 100.2 24.5 27.9 46.1 49.6 6.7 13.6 9.8 15.4 1.7 1.2 2.7 4.3 28.4

 

 National Rank 397 186 423 500

 

  • As you can see from the stats, the two have very similar bottom lines. Harrison Barnes has been better in the ACC in terms of producing points, but he is also forcing it more. The previous two games that UNC played, Barnes shot a lot of threes when he didn't need to. He made a couple, but he also missed a lot.
  • In terms of efficiency (KenPom, the last comparison on the chart), Travis McKie blows Harrison Barnes out of the water. He plays more minutes for his team (a lot out of necessity), yet he doesn't force his offensive game, which shows up in the offensive rating, as well as % of shots/possessions that end with him. He rebounds better offensively and defensively %-wise than Barnes has. I will, however, point out that Barnes has much better rebounders around him than Travis McKie does, so that is probably a reason for some of discrepancies. I think in the long run of all the stats, they are on equal terms though regarding the teams that each play on. Barnes will not have as many stats because there is a lot more talent on UNC's roster, but McKie has been more efficient than Barnes has, despite not having as much offensive firepower on his team.
  • Both of these players have done very well for their respective teams. Barnes was expected to do much more (media pressure), but has still had a good year on a very good UNC team. Travis McKie has been the bright spot on a pretty bad team, and gives it his all every single night. The stats are similar, but I will give the nod to McKie for the stats-based argument because of how he has gone about accruing them.
  • When players are playing at a similar level, the voting will come down to things such as: how the team is doing, the "watchability" of the player, and the name value. Harrison Barnes wins all three of these categories in pretty much a landslide. UNC is obviously a much better team than Wake Forest. Harrison Barnes is a highlight reel (although Assane Sene would argue that Travis McKie is too). The media all know who Harrison Barnes is, and not as many know about Travis McKie. Barnes will continue to get a lot of visibility as the season winds down with the Tar Heels playing good basketball, also because of the way he has improved. McKie will not get this visibility because the Deacs only have some bubble teams, and a couple of below average teams left.
Conclusion: Harrison Barnes will win the ACC FOY, and it will probably not be that close in the media voting. He will deserve winning it (as would Travis), and I will certainly have no problem with it. He played on the better team, and improved throughout the year after a very slow start.

 If Travis McKie does not get second place, I will be extremely outraged and demand explanations. The margin of victory for Barnes will probably not be justified, as the media will cover their backs on the unrealistic expectations they had for him when the season started. 

If the award were the "most valuable freshman", then it would absolutely have to be Travis McKie. Without him on our team I shudder to think of how much worse this year could have been. I just want Travis McKie to get the respect he deserves. He plays on a team that is not very good, but he has given it his all and put up very impressive numbers for a freshman. Regardless of whether or not he wins the award, he is very, very important for Wake Forest going forward, and if he continues to play this way for the next three years then he could be one of the best players to ever wear the Wake Forest uniform.

Kudos to you Travis, and from a diehard Wake Forest fan...thank you for representing Wake Forest in the best way possible both on and off the court. It is an honor to have you on our team and all the fans appreciate what you do for us night in and night out.

 

Play the March To The Championship game and you could win a trip for two to Las Vegas! Look for the code inside specially-marked 12-packs of Bud Light and enter the code at Facebook.com/BudLight

-- No Purchase Necessary. Open to U.S. residents (except CA & TX) 21+. For a chance to win a Grand or First Prize, Game Period 1 begins 3PM CST on 2/14 & ends 3PM CDT on 3/18. For a chance to win a First Prize only, Game Period 2 begins 3:00:01PM CDT on 3/18 & ends 3PM CDT on 4/30. To participate, obtain a Code from inside specially-marked packages of Bud Light beer or to request a Code without purchase, visit budlight.com/freecode during a Game Period. Limit one (1) free Code request/day/person or email address. To play, text HOOPS to BEERS (23377) & follow prompts or visit budlight.com/freecode & follow instructions. See Official Rules inside package or at budlight.com/freecode for complete details. Void in CA, TX & where prohibited. Enjoy Responsibly –  ©2011 Anheuser-Busch, Inc., Bud Light® Beer, St. Louis, MO.